Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Shefi1280's avatar

"High social tone deafness". I can sympathize (a little). Growing up middle-class, I had no contact with a higher class of people. Plus, education and media teach us middle-class folk that "upper class" are either bubble-enclosed twits who have no idea how "real" people live (think Monty Python's "Upper Class Twit of the Year", or PG Wodehouse's Bertie Wooster) or complete boorish snobs (e.g. William McCordle in "Gosford Park" or Mr. Hurst in "Pride & Prejudice"). Either way, they have nothing of value to offer. Austen's (and later Dickens') point was that finer feelings exist in different people regardless of social class.

Only in university did I interact with a few upper-class men. Some seemed to me almost caricatures of the popular imagination and I could not take them seriously ("the country is going to the dogs!" exclaimed one because the wait staff were slow in bringing him his food). Others were clearly more cultured and much better spoken than me, and that was clearly due to their upbringing, both family and school ("could we say 'the slings and arrows', here, sir?" offered one in a translation tutorial, and I admired the easy familiarity he had with Hamlet's words, which I did not, to my chagrin, immediately recognize, even tho I'd "studied" the play).

JT Gatto provided more concrete examples of how high-status people raise their children: certainly differently from how I was raised, and I suspect how most people were.

LT probably has no conception therefore that there is such a thing as higher status: everyone is fair game, and those that think they aren't are simply snobs who need to be taken down a few pegs. And he's the one to do it!

Expand full comment
SirHamster's avatar

"One sentence and we know exactly what it is."

The impossibility of faking. You might get away with it for a moment, but you probably don't even know how many tells you're broadcasting by what you do and don't do.

Become content with what you are, and then learn how to build from what you have.

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts